| Wt | Winner | Result | Loser | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 125 | Ayden Smith · Rutgers | DEC 6-1 Decision | Tyson Lane | confirmed |
| 133 | T.K. Davis · Gardner-Webb | TF 15-0 Tech fall | Patrick Adams | confirmed |
| 141 | Joey Olivieri · Rutgers | FALL Fall | Dominic DiTullio · Gardner-Webb | confirmed |
| 141 | Dominic DiTullio · Gardner-Webb | FALL Fall | Daniel Haws | non-D1, not counted |
| 149 | Andrew Clark · Rutgers | MD 12-1 Major decision | Drew Pepin · Gardner-Webb | confirmed |
| 149 | Drew Pepin · Gardner-Webb | FALL Fall | Joseph Innamorato | non-D1, not counted |
| 157 | Anthony White | DEC 6-4 Decision | Joseph Giordano · Gardner-Webb | confirmed |
| 157 | Joseph Giordano · Gardner-Webb | TF 29-0 Tech fall | Colin Neal | non-D1, not counted |
| 165 | Ryan Ford · Rutgers | DEC 11-5 Decision | Nathan McCartney | confirmed |
| 174 | Lenny Pinto · Rutgers | TF 21-5 Tech fall | Isaiah Guerrero · Gardner-Webb | confirmed |
| 184 | Shane Cartagena-Walsh · Rutgers | MD 17-5 Major decision | Hadyn Danals | confirmed |
| 184 | Isaiah Guerrero · Gardner-Webb | FALL Fall | Luke McGovern | non-D1, not counted |
| 197 | Joshua McCutchen · Gardner-Webb | MD Major decision | Angelo Piazza | non-D1, not counted |
| 197 | PJ Casale · Rutgers | MD 10-0 Major decision | Joshua McCutchen · Gardner-Webb | confirmed |
| 285 | Hunter Catka · Rutgers | TF 20-3 Tech fall | Rocky Files | confirmed |
Results for 2025-26 come from the schools' own box scores and from tournament brackets imported by hand, through Nov 2, 2025. A dual whose page printed no box score, or an open that was not exported, is missing here. Bouts against non-Division I opponents are listed but not counted in records.How ScrapStat counts.